By                    Andrew Lisa

More Lessons: What Gen Z Can Learn From Millennials’ Money Mistakes And: What Gen X Can Learn From Boomers’ Money Mistakes

Millennials Should Break Retirement Savings Tradition

Although they didn’t save as much as their parents, Gen Xers tended to save the exact same way when they did.

“One common mistake we see with Gen Xers who have been good savers is that a large majority of their retirement savings, if not all of it, is in pre-tax accounts such as 401(k)s and traditional IRAs,” said Matt Hylland, a financial planner at Arnold and Mote Wealth Management in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. 

Had they known about the flexibility and potentially huge tax benefits of Roth alternatives when they started their careers, many would likely go back and switch if they could.

See: How Each Generation Has Been Affected Financially By the Pandemic

“Today, millennials have much easier access to Roth savings, whether through employer plans or just a Roth IRA,” Hylland said. “A lot of millennials that we see today should be taking more advantage of Roth savings today, something that a lot of Gen Xers did not do.”

By following their parents down the 401(k) path instead of investigating the benefits of Roth savings, according to Hylland, many Gen Xers: 

  • Saddled themselves with enormous future tax bills that are unavoidable with pretax accounts, which treat retirement withdrawals as income.
  • Will be forced to take required minimum distributions that could bump them into higher tax brackets.
  • Will be heavily penalized if they have to make early withdrawals, unlike Roth IRAs.

More: Why Gen Xers Are Feeling the ‘Financial Squeeze’ — and What To Do About It

Millennials Should Let Gen X Be the Last of the Old Guard

It’s not only nuts-and-bolts stuff like choosing the right tax-preferred retirement account. Brendan Butler, of the personal finance YouTube channel Brendan Fitness and Money, thinks millennials need to reconsider the entire concept of wealth, success and financial freedom — particularly as it applies to standards that were set in a different time. 

Read: Common Money Myths About Millennials

“Gen X is more trusting in the stereotypical American dream being both what is desirable and what is to be expected,” Butler said. “As millennials, we need to be far more skeptical of this view. Are we sure we want a 30-year mortgage on the largest house we can possibly secure financing for to go along with our student loan debt and auto loan? Or would we prefer the nimble lifestyle of a digital nomad? Maybe a used RV and a WiFi hotspot are more appealing than a 2,000-square-foot ranch. Think long and hard before committing to a particular mold or method.” 

Hit the Road: Companies That Let You Work From Anywhere

Adaptability Is the Key to Their Success

These differences in generational attitudes might already have benefitted millennials, an entrepreneurial generation that drove revolutions like the gig economy and the transition from software to mobile apps. Their aging predecessors in Gen X did not always move with the current.

“Gen X is more accepting of the status quo than necessary,” Butler said. “Get a college degree. Land a job. Buy a house. Invest for retirement someday. It’s a flawed model. They have a much higher belief in this system than younger generations and we millennials are justified in our skepticism. Not only will that model not work for them, but it definitely doesn’t align with the different priorities held by many millennials, like experiences over possessions, and prioritizing purpose, innovation, and flexibility.”

  • 5 Things Most Americans Don’t Know About Social Security
  • Social Security Benefits Might Get Cut Early — What Does It Mean for You?
  • How To Use a Credit Card Like a Pro This Holiday Season
  • How To Refinance a Mortgage

Last updated: Oct. 28, 2021